For sale Home

Listed Sep 21, 2026

$599,000 Est. $3,962/mo

1021 East Cayuga Street

  • 8

    Beds

  • 3

    Baths

  • 2,532

    Sq ft

The story

Income-producing opportunity in Southeast Seminole Heights! This versatile property offers three separate living spaces across two buildings and generated $57,600 in gross rental income in 2025, according to the seller. The main residence features generously sized bedrooms and distinctive architectural character, including arched openings, a living-room fireplace, and a covered front porch. Its flexible layout can function as a 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home or as a 2-bedroom residence with a dedicated office, den, or flex room. Estimated market rent is approximately $1,900-$2,000 per month. The detached two-story accessory building contains two updated residences. The downstairs 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom unit is estimated to rent for approximately $1,350 per month, while the upstairs 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom unit is estimated at approximately $1,550 per month. The rear building offers separate access, parking, and convenient entry from the back alley, providing additional privacy and independence from the main residence. Combined estimated rents total $4,800 per month, or $57,600 annually in potential gross rental income. The flexible configuration makes this an attractive option for a full investment property, multigenerational living, or an owner-occupant seeking to offset housing expenses with rental income. The detached ADU building is leased through August 29, 2027 (Unit #B) and Unit #C is leased through September 30, 2027. Located approximately 3 miles from Downtown Tampa and minutes from I-275, with convenient access to Armature Works, Ybor City, Busch Gardens, USF, dining, entertainment, and major employment centers. No HOA. Buyer to verify zoning, permitted use, room dimensions, rental information, and all details material to the buyer’s intended use.

Facts & features

Home type

Home

Year built

1926

Floors

1

Price per sq ft

$237

Included features

  • Fireplace

    Yes

  • Cooling

    Central Air, Mini-Split Unit(s)

  • Heating

    Central, Electric

  • Appliances

    Range, Refrigerator

  • Flooring

    Carpet, Tile

  • Roof

    Shingle

  • Exterior

    Lighting

  • Water Source

    Public

  • Sewer

    Public Sewer

Mortgage calculator

Estimated monthly payment

$3,962 /mo

7% rate · 30-yr fixed · 20% down

  • Principal & interest $3,188
  • Property tax $599
  • Insurance $175

Includes principal, interest, taxes & insurance.

Your Property Journey

Interested in this, or something like it?

Submit an inquiry

Drop your details and we will help you find what you are looking for.

Not quite. Help me find the right one

Talk it through or type it out, whichever feels easiest.

Your contact details

An agent will reach out personally, no automated calls.

Smart Assistant

Hi, how can I help you find your dream home?

Tap the voice button to talk, or just start typing.

Tap anywhere to fix a word or add more

Tap stop when you’re done. You can edit the text before searching.

By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms.

Listing Broker

KELLER WILLIAMS ST PETE REALTY

Broker Name

KELLER WILLIAMS ST PETE REALTY

Agent

Sean Sandifer