Homes for Sale in Fisher Island, FL

5 homes for sale · Updated September 25, 2026

Market snapshot for Fisher Island, FL

Median price
$17,100,000
Average price
$18,980,000
Highest price
$34,000,000
Avg price / sqft
$3,577/sqft
Avg home size
4,954 sqft
Avg days on market
373
Avg year built
2007
Avg beds / baths
4.4 bd / 5.4 ba

All homes for sale in Fisher Island