Homes for Sale in Overgaard, AZ
179 homes for sale ยท Updated August 12, 2026
Market snapshot for Overgaard, AZ
- Median price
- $385,000
- Average price
- $432,524
- Highest price
- $1,499,000
- Avg price / sqft
- $293/sqft
- Avg home size
- 1,508 sqft
- Avg days on market
- 83
- Avg year built
- 2000
- Avg beds / baths
- 2.6 bd / 2 ba
Homes by bedrooms
Homes by property type
Homes by price
Homes by neighborhood
- Homes in Bison Ranch (7)
- Homes in Bison Resort Cabins (5)
- Homes in Forest Trails (10)
- Homes in Holiday Forest Sub (6)
- Homes in Mogollon Air Park (9)
- Homes in Mogollon Estates (5)
- Homes in Overgaard Unsubdivided (14)
- Homes in Pinecrest Lake (6)
- Homes in Pineland Acres (6)
- Homes in Timberlake Pines (17)
- Homes in Zane Grey Acres (11)
Homes by zip code
- Homes in 85928 Zip Code (41)
- Homes in 85933 Zip Code (178)