5936 Cedar Street

Welcome to Mutiny Bay—the most coveted waterfront on Whidbey Island—where 60 feet of no-bank, sugar-sand frontage puts the Olympic Mountains, passing shipping lanes and ever-changing tides at your doorstep every single day. The main house offers 4 bedrooms plus a waterside office with private balcony, a light-filled loft area, and a cook's kitchen built for gathering—all opening to expansive decks that carry indoor comfort right out to the beach. Gather around the cozy fireplace on cool island evenings, then step outside to a covered BBQ area and private courtyard made for effortless entertaining. The 2-stall garage with boathouse stores every toy for life on the water, while an expansive guest house with loft sleeping area and custom built-ins welcomes visitors in true Whidbey style. A rare 5-bedroom septic system with dedicated reserve area adds real value and flexibility for the way you want to live. Step from your door to the beach for crabbing, kayaking, paddleboarding, beachcombing and sunsets that never repeat. Whether hosting a crowd or savoring a quiet morning coffee at the water's edge, this is the quintessential Island waterfront retreat—thoughtfully designed, impeccably located, and ready for its next chapter. Homes on no-bank Mutiny Bay frontage of this caliber rarely come to market. Come experience the surf, the salt air, and the feeling of home.